Celeb Glow
updates | April 05, 2026

Questions tagged [first-order-logic]

Ask Question

For questions about formal deduction of first-order logic formula or metamathematical properties of first-order logic.

4,734 questions
1 vote 0 answers 17 views

Understanding the use of the Axiom of Choice in David Marker's proof of Compactness

I am trying to understand the use of the Axiom of Choice in the proof of Lemma 2.1.8 (page 37 below) in David Marker's Model Theory: An Introduction Pages 35 and 36 can be found here. Lemma 2.1.8 is ... user avatar John
  • 3,118
1 vote 0 answers 23 views

Can we reduce the number of occurrences of the metavariable in Peano Arithmetic's axiom schema of induction?

Is there an axiomatization of Peano arithmetic where the axiom schema contains fewer than 4 distinct occurrences of the metavariable? Ideally, as few as possible. The immediate motivation is to come ... user avatar Greg Nisbet
  • 6,946
1 vote 0 answers 29 views

Beginner question about first-order logic

In first order logic, is it correct to say that: $\vdash\forall x(A\rightarrow B)\rightarrow\forall xB$ if and only if $\vdash\forall x(\neg A\rightarrow B)$ The right-to-left is easy to argue for. I ... user avatar saulkripke321
  • 21
1 vote 1 answer 84 views

First-order logic: where's the the flaw in this argument?

There must be a flaw in the following argument, but I don't see it at the moment. Who can point it out? In first-order logic, suppose that a structure $\mathfrak{U}$ is a model of the formula ($x = 3$... user avatar Adam Dingle
  • 121
0 votes 0 answers 43 views

Requirements for being a model of ZF

It is a follow up to this other question Is it true that "Axiom of Choice is true or Axiom of Choice is false"? In order to proof that something is a model of ZF, what should I do? I need to ... user avatar Eduard
  • 184
3 votes 1 answer 51 views

How to apply axiom of choice on the universe of sets? [duplicate]

If we have $\forall x(x\in X\to\exists y(y\in Y\land\varphi(x,y)))$, then we can define a function $f$ from $X$ to $\mathcal P(Y)\setminus\{\emptyset\}$ such that $f(x)=\{y\in Y|\varphi(x,y)\}$, and ... user avatar zap kabosu
  • 31
2 votes 0 answers 31 views

Is there work on free logic in algebraic logic?

Has there been work on algebraic versions of free logic? I've been playing with mechanizing various forms of algebraic logic. I think maybe free logic could simplify some things. Trivially you can add ... user avatar Molossus Spondee
  • 1,133
0 votes 2 answers 30 views

This conditional statement is evaluated as true (by the program Tarski's world) however it seems false could you help detect my mistake?

So the way I read the statement is: there is an object x such that if it's a cube then it is between a and b. However, there is a cube but it is not between a and b, making the statement false. The ... user avatar exodus
  • 101
0 votes 0 answers 24 views

Measure of similarity between boolean formulas?

Apologies, if this is a dumb question... Is there a measure of structural similarity between Boolean formulas A and B, such that if we know some information about A's behavior under a set of inputs $... user avatar ragnacode
  • 35
1 vote 1 answer 55 views

Soundness and Completeness for a single Model Only?

Question modified to hopefully answer the questions (I'm a physicist to all might not be mathematically watertight) In Enderton "A Mathematical Introduction to Logic", logical Implication is ... user avatar Little Cheese
  • 555
1 vote 1 answer 59 views

Downsides of defining $\models$ to be false when there's a mismatch in signature between the structure and formula.

The way that $M \models \varphi$ is usually defined, we know implicitly that for some $L$, $M$ is an $L$-structure and $\varphi$ is an $L$-sentence. I'm curious what the downsides are to defining $M \... user avatar Greg Nisbet
  • 6,946
0 votes 0 answers 40 views

Making sense of: "there is an uncountable set" is a logical consequence of $\mathrm{ZFC}$, yet $\mathrm{ZFC}$ is satisfiable in a countable domain.

As I learn the Compactness and Löwenheim-Skolem theorems of first-order logic and I begin to have a better understanding of what they really mean, something has me baffled. As I have learned it, the ... user avatar John
  • 3,118
1 vote 2 answers 51 views

Witnesses in the Henkin construction and the canonical model

See the images below, from Model theory: An Introduction, by David Marker: In the proof of Lemma 2.1.7 the canonical model is defined using equivalence classes of constant symbols of $\mathcal{L}$, ... user avatar John
  • 3,118
2 votes 0 answers 50 views

Link between Tarski Truth, Negation, Consistency and Deductions

In Enderton "A Mathematical Introduction to Logic" negation in a given structure M is defined as: $$(M \models \neg A) \; \Longleftrightarrow \; [\text{ not true } (M \models A)] \tag{1}$$. ... user avatar Little Cheese
  • 555
1 vote 0 answers 30 views

Identifying fragments of First Order Logic, where the number of models increases strictly monotonically with the domain size?

Given a function-free first order logic language with only universal quantification. The problem of model counting aims at finding the number of models that an FOL formula of the form $\forall {\bf{x}}... user avatar SagarM
  • 1,515

15 30 50 per page12345316